I see your Silly Bandz and raise you jelly bracelets. I think these were a thing in the '80s, but they made a huge resurgence in the early-mid 2000s. Each color was
Amazon.com: Sosation120 Pcs Silicone Bands Bracelets Colored Rubber Bands Bracelets Sea Animal and Vehicles Silly String Elastic in Fun Shapes for Kids (random Color) : Toys & Games